5 Tips for Choosing a Cat Sitter

Cats are famously independent, but when you need to leave home for more than a day, even your self-sufficient feline friend requires care. Whether it’s for a weekend getaway or an extended vacation, finding the right cat sitter can make all the difference between a stress-free trip and constant worry.

Unlike dogs, cats don’t usually fare well in unfamiliar environments, which is why most cat owners prefer in-home sitting. But how do you choose someone trustworthy, experienced, and capable of handling your cat’s unique quirks?

This guide covers 5 key tips for choosing a cat sitter who will give you peace of mind and your cat a purr-worthy experience.

Why Choosing the Right Cat Sitter Matters

Cats thrive on routine. They like their food at a certain time, naps in a specific spot, and often don’t appreciate sudden changes. A good cat sitter:

• Maintains feeding and care routines
• Recognizes signs of illness or stress
• Keeps your cat safe and your home secure
• Reduces anxiety for both you and your pet

Let’s explore how to ensure you’re hiring someone who checks all the right boxes.

Tip 1: Choose a Sitter with Cat-Specific Experience

Not all pet sitters are created equal. Someone who’s great with dogs or exotic pets may not have the finesse to care for a cat properly. Cats have subtle behaviors, and missing early signs of distress can be dangerous.

What to look for:

• Prior experience specifically with cats (not just general pet sitting)
• Knowledge of feline behavior, body language, and communication
• Comfort with tasks like litter box cleaning, administering medication, and grooming

Questions to ask:

• “How many cats have you cared for in the past?”
• “Are you familiar with signs of feline illness?”
• “How do you handle a shy or fearful cat?”

Bonus: Ask if they have completed any pet first aid or cat behavior training courses.

Tip 2: Get References and Read Reviews

Whether you find a sitter through an agency, app (like Rover or Meowtel), or word of mouth, always do your homework.

Check:

• Online reviews and ratings
• References from past clients (especially cat owners)
• Social media or local recommendations

Red flags:

• Negative reviews about reliability or cleanliness
• No proof of identity or vague service descriptions
• Hesitation to provide references

If you’re using a professional service, ask about background checks and bonding or insurance for peace of mind.

Tip 3: Schedule a Meet-and-Greet

Never hire a cat sitter sight unseen. A face-to-face (or face-to-fur) meeting helps you assess how they interact with your cat and lets you explain your care instructions in person.

What to observe:

• Do they approach your cat gently and respectfully?
• Are they calm, confident, and friendly with animals?
• Does your cat seem relaxed, curious, or at ease around them?

This visit also lets the sitter see:

• Where food, litter, and supplies are kept
• How to access your home (keys, alarm codes)
• Any specific needs like medications or hiding spots

Bring a checklist or leave printed instructions for clarity.

Tip 4: Discuss Duties and Expectations Clearly

Once you’ve found a potential sitter, clarify everything up front. That way, both sides understand what’s expected—and your cat gets consistent, thoughtful care.

Important details to cover:

• Visit frequency: Once or twice daily? How long per visit?
• Feeding schedule: Amount, timing, wet vs. dry food
• Litter box duties: Scoop daily, change entirely after X days
• Playtime and enrichment: Toy preferences, interactive play
• Health monitoring: Noticing lethargy, vomiting, appetite changes

Also, cover household tasks such as:

• Bringing in mail or packages
• Watering plants
• Turning lights on/off to deter burglars

Put everything in writing—this prevents misunderstandings later.

Tip 5: Ensure Backup and Emergency Planning

Even a reliable sitter can get sick, stuck in traffic, or have an emergency. A professional cat sitter should always have a backup plan.

Ask about:

• Emergency contacts
• Their backup sitter protocol
• How they handle vet emergencies

Leave your vet’s contact info and a signed vet release form authorizing treatment. Note where your cat carrier and emergency kit are stored. Share your travel contact info and the name of someone local to assist if needed.

READ ALSO: Tips for Keeping Your Dog’s Coat Shiny and Healthy

Bonus: Use Technology for Added Peace of Mind

Some sitters offer updates via:

• Text or email
• Photos or short videos of your cat
• Pet cams with live-stream access

These small touches can make a big difference when you’re miles away missing your fur baby.

FAQs

Should I use a professional cat sitter or ask a friend?

A friend or neighbor may seem convenient, but a professional sitter is trained, insured, and more likely to recognize health issues or behavioral red flags. However, if your friend is a fellow cat lover with experience, it can work too just clarify expectations.

What should I include in my cat care instructions?

Include:

• Feeding schedule and quantities
• Medication directions
• Litter box instructions
• Hiding spots and temperament notes
• Emergency contacts (vet, nearby family)
• House access info (alarm, key location)

How far in advance should I book a cat sitter?

For holidays or busy seasons, book 3–4 weeks in advance. For regular weekends or mid-week trips, 1–2 weeks is usually sufficient.

What’s a fair rate for a cat sitter?

Rates vary by location and experience:

• Basic visits: $20–$35 per visit
• Overnight stays: $60–$100 per night
• Medication or special care: May cost extra

Urban areas and holiday periods typically have higher rates.

My cat is shy—will they hide the whole time?

Possibly. That’s why it’s important to choose a sitter with cat experience, who can recognize whether your cat is simply shy or showing signs of stress or illness. Provide comfort zones, like cozy hideouts or a favorite blanket.

What if the sitter misses a visit?

Reliable sitters keep strict schedules. Ask if they offer GPS or timestamped check-ins. In case of a missed visit, you should have an emergency contact or neighbor as backup.

Can my sitter stay overnight instead of making daily visits?

Yes, many sitters offer overnight services, which is ideal for cats needing extra care, medication, or companionship. It also gives you added home security.

Is it better to board my cat or use a sitter?

Most cats are less stressed staying at home, especially older or anxious cats. Boarding may be suitable for sociable or younger cats, but can expose them to illness or stress from unfamiliar settings.