How to Create a DIY Pet Toy on a Budget

How to Create a DIY Pet Toy on a Budget: Creating DIY pet toys is one of the most rewarding, cost-effective, and creative ways to bond with your furry companion. Whether you own a cat, dog, rabbit, bird, or another pet, making toys at home is not only budget-friendly but also environmentally sustainable you can repurpose household materials that might otherwise go to waste.

In this in-depth guide, we’ll walk you through why DIY pet toys are valuable, the materials you can use, specific project ideas for dogs and cats, safety tips.

Why Make DIY Pet Toys?

Store-bought toys can be expensive and they don’t always last. Many break easily, pose choking hazards, or are made from non-eco-friendly materials. DIY toys solve many of these problems.

Benefits of DIY Pet Toys:

• Cost-effective: Use items you already have.
• Customizable: Tailor to your pet’s size, age, and play style.
• Eco-conscious: Recycle old clothes, cardboard, and more.
• Bonding: Making toys can be a family project involving kids.
• Mental & Physical Stimulation: Homemade toys are great for enrichment.

Materials You Can Reuse

Before heading to the craft store, look around your home! Many safe and reusable items make perfect materials for DIY pet toys.

Safety Guidelines for DIY Pet Toys

Even homemade toys can pose risks if not crafted carefully. Always prioritize your pet’s safety over appearance or complexity.

Safety Tips:

• Avoid small parts: Items that can be swallowed or choked on.
• Non-toxic materials only: Use pet-safe dyes, glues, and fabrics.
• Supervise play: Especially when first introducing the toy.
• Replace worn toys: Once a toy starts falling apart, remove it.
• Size appropriately: Toys should match the size and strength of your pet.

DIY Pet Toy Projects by Animal Type

Let’s explore specific toy ideas based on pet type, with instructions and variations.

DIY Toys for Dogs

1. Braided Tug Toy from Old T-Shirts

What You Need:

• 2–3 old T-shirts
• Scissors

Instructions:

1. Cut T-shirts into long strips (~2 inches wide).
2. Group strips into three bunches.
3. Tie a knot at one end.
4. Braid tightly and knot the other end.

Why It Works:

• Dogs love tugging and chewing.
• Washable and reusable.

2. Treat Puzzle Bottle

What You Need:

• Empty plastic bottle (without cap)
• Dry treats or kibble

Instructions:

1. Rinse and dry the bottle.
2. Cut small holes large enough for treats to fall out.
3. Fill with kibble or treats.
4. Let your dog roll and shake to dispense food.

Pro Tip: Use a durable bottle to avoid sharp edges.

3. Sock Ball with Scent

What You Need:

• Old clean sock
• Tennis ball
• Optional: a dab of peanut butter or your scent

Instructions:

1. Insert the ball into the sock.
2. Knot the sock to hold it in place.
3. Let your dog chew, carry, and toss it.

DIY Toys for Cats

1. Cardboard Box Maze

What You Need:

• Several cardboard boxes
• Utility knife (adults only)
• Tape

Instructions:

1. Cut entrance holes on multiple boxes.
2. Tape boxes together in a maze shape.
3. Add dangling string or crinkly paper inside for fun.

Why It Works:

• Cats love to hide, explore, and pounce.

2. Toilet Roll Puzzle Toy

What You Need:

• Empty toilet paper rolls
• Cardboard base or shoebox
• Glue

Instructions:

1. Stand up rolls in a box or glue to a flat base.
2. Hide treats or catnip inside some of the rolls.
3. Let your cat dig and paw through to find them.

3. No-Sew Catnip Sock Toy

What You Need:

• Old sock
• Catnip
• Polyfill or scrap fabric

Instructions:

1. Fill the sock with catnip and stuffing.
2. Tie the end into a knot.
3. Toss to your cat and enjoy the show.

DIY Toys for Rabbits & Small Animals

1. Hanging Treat Mobile

What You Need:

• Twine (natural, unwaxed)
• Clothespins
• Herbs or small veggie slices

Instructions:

1. String twine across the top of the cage.
2. Clip small snacks to the line with clothespins.
3. Watch your rabbit stretch and forage.

2. Cardboard Tunnel

What You Need:

• Large cardboard tubes (e.g., mailing tubes)
• Scissors

Instructions:

1. Cut holes for multiple entry points.
2. Place hay or treats inside.
3. Use as a burrow, chew toy, and obstacle course.

DIY Toys for Birds

1. Paper Shred Ball

What You Need:

• Non-toxic paper (cut into strips)
• Small paper bag or muffin liner

Instructions:

1. Crumple strips into a ball or stuff into a paper cup.
2. Hide a treat inside.
3. Hang or place in cage for shredding fun.

2. Mirror Toy with Bell

What You Need:

• Old compact mirror
• String
• Bell or metal jingle

Instructions:

1. Hang mirror with a bell attached.
2. Secure with bird-safe string.
3. Ensure no sharp edges.

READ ALSO: Best Pet Carriers for Air Travel in 2025

Enhancing Mental Enrichment Through DIY Toys

DIY pet toys don’t just entertain—they stimulate your pet’s brain. Incorporate problem-solving, scent work, and interactive features to mimic natural behaviors.

Enrichment Ideas:

• Rotating toys weekly prevents boredom.
• Use food puzzles to slow eating and challenge pets.
• Add your scent or other animals’ scents (e.g., catnip or an old sock) for novelty.
• Freeze toys (like stuffed KONGs) for longer-lasting fun.

Mental stimulation is just as important as physical activity—boredom can lead to anxiety, destruction, and obesity.

FAQs

Are homemade pet toys safe?

Yes, when made correctly. Always use non-toxic, pet-safe materials and supervise pets during play. Replace worn or broken toys.

What’s the best DIY toy for a puppy?

A braided t-shirt tug toy is great. It satisfies teething needs and helps with training. For added appeal, freeze it slightly to soothe gums.

Can I use essential oils in pet toys?

Avoid most essential oils. Many (like tea tree, citrus, peppermint) are toxic to pets, especially cats. Instead, use dried herbs like catnip or parsley for enrichment.

How often should I rotate toys?

Weekly is ideal. Rotating toys keeps things fresh, exciting, and engaging. Store unused toys in a bin and reintroduce them later.

What materials should I never use?

Avoid:

• Rubber bands
• Sharp metal parts
• Treated wood or painted surfaces
• Plastic bags
• Toxic glues or dyes

Can I give cardboard to pets?

Yes! Untreated, plain cardboard is generally safe for chewing and playing (especially for rabbits and cats). Avoid boxes with staples, glossy finishes, or heavy ink.

What are signs a toy isn’t safe?

• Missing parts or fraying strings
• Sharp edges
• Strong chemical smells
• Pet shows signs of ingestion or choking

When in doubt, throw it out.

What’s a good way to make toys more appealing?

Add scent (catnip, peanut butter, dried herbs), use interesting textures (crinkle paper, rope), or hide treats inside to encourage exploration.

 Do all pets like toys?

Most do—but preferences vary. Dogs may prefer tug toys, cats like interactive puzzles or chase toys, and rabbits like chewable tunnels. Try different types to learn your pet’s style.

Are DIY toys better than store-bought ones?

They can be just as effective and more personal. However, some professional toys are better for long-term durability or specific health needs (like dental chews). Use a mix of both.