Are Harnesses or Collars Better for Walking Dogs?

When it comes to walking your dog, one of the most important decisions you’ll make is choosing the right walking gear: a harness or a collar. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice for you and your dog depends on several factors such as your dog’s size, breed, behavior, and health.

In this detailed guide, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both harnesses and collars, helping you make an informed decision for your dog’s walks.

Collars: The Traditional Option

Collars are the most common and traditional option for dog walking. A collar is a simple loop that goes around your dog’s neck, and it often holds an ID tag and a leash attachment point.

Pros of Using a Collar

1. Simple and Easy to Use: Collars are lightweight, easy to put on, and require little adjustment. Most dogs are familiar with collars, and they usually don’t mind wearing them.
2. Versatility: Collars can serve multiple purposes. This versatility makes them a popular option for everyday use, even when you’re not walking your dog.
3. Variety of Styles: Collars come in a wide range of styles, from simple nylon bands to fashionable designs. There are also adjustable collars that can grow with your dog, making them a great long-term investment.
4. Ideal for Dogs with Short Walks: Collars can be a good option for dogs that are not prone to pulling or lunging during walks. If your dog tends to walk calmly and is well-behaved, a collar may be sufficient for your needs.
5. Lower Cost: Collars are often less expensive than harnesses, making them an affordable choice for many dog owners.

Cons of Using a Collar

1. Potential for Neck Injury: The most significant concern with collars, particularly for dogs that pull, is the potential for neck and trachea injuries. When a dog pulls on the leash, the pressure is directly applied to their neck, which can cause pain, discomfort, and even long-term damage to their neck, throat, and spine. This is especially a concern for dogs with short noses (brachycephalic breeds like Pugs or Bulldogs) and dogs prone to pulling.
2. Limited Control: Collars offer less control over your dog’s movements, particularly when they are pulling or trying to chase something. Unlike a harness, which spreads the pressure across the dog’s body, a collar may only put pressure on one point, making it difficult to redirect their attention or prevent unwanted behavior.
3. Can Cause Chafing or Discomfort: If a collar is too tight, it can cause chafing or irritation around your dog’s neck. Collars that aren’t adjusted properly can also slip off or cause discomfort, especially if your dog has a long or thick coat.
4. Not Suitable for All Dogs: Collars are not the best choice for certain dogs, particularly those with respiratory issues, delicate necks, or behavioral problems like excessive pulling. Puppies and small dogs, in particular, may have more sensitive necks, and a collar may cause them discomfort or injury.

Harnesses: The Supportive Alternative

A harness is an alternative to a collar, designed to wrap around your dog’s body, usually across the chest and around the rib cage. Harnesses distribute the pressure of the leash more evenly, which can be a safer and more comfortable option for many dogs.

Pros of Using a Harness

1. Better Control and Safety: Harnesses give you more control over your dog, especially if they tend to pull. With a harness, the force is distributed over the dog’s body rather than concentrated on the neck. This makes it safer for dogs that pull or lunge, reducing the risk of neck and trachea injuries.
2. Ideal for Dogs That Pull: If your dog tends to pull on walks, a harness can help prevent strain on their neck and back. Harnesses designed for pulling, like no-pull harnesses, feature front clips that encourage your dog to stop pulling by redirecting their movement when they lunge forward.
3. Better for Certain Breeds: Some breeds, particularly those with short or flat noses (like Bulldogs or Pugs), are more prone to respiratory issues. A harness is a gentler option for these dogs, as it avoids putting pressure on the neck and throat, making it safer for their health.
4. Prevents Escaping: Some dogs, particularly smaller or more agile breeds, may be able to slip out of a collar if it’s not properly fitted. Harnesses are typically harder to escape from because they cover more of the dog’s body and have more secure fastening mechanisms.
5. Comfort for Long Walks: If you plan to take your dog on long walks, a harness may be the more comfortable option. By distributing the pressure more evenly across the body, harnesses reduce the likelihood of chafing or discomfort, making them ideal for extended walks.
6. Variety of Styles for Different Needs: There are many types of harnesses to choose from, including step-in harnesses, over-the-head harnesses, no-pull harnesses, and adjustable harnesses. These options allow you to choose one that best suits your dog’s size, behavior, and needs.

Cons of Using a Harness

1. Can Be Difficult to Put On: Unlike collars, which are usually simple to slip on, harnesses can be trickier to put on, particularly for dogs that aren’t accustomed to wearing one. Some harnesses require a little practice and patience to put on, and some dogs may resist at first.
2. Bulkier Than Collars: Harnesses are bulkier than collars, and they may feel uncomfortable to some dogs, especially if they’re not accustomed to wearing them. Some dogs may initially resist wearing a harness until they become familiar with it.
3. More Expensive: Generally, harnesses are more expensive than collars. If you’re on a budget, a collar may be a more economical option, particularly if your dog doesn’t need the extra control or comfort that a harness provides.
4. Limited Use for Identification: While a harness can hold an ID tag, it is not as convenient as a collar. Many dog owners prefer to use collars for identification because they are easier to spot and more comfortable for daily wear. However, you can always use a collar in addition to a harness if you want the benefits of both.
5. Potential for Chafing: While harnesses are generally gentler on a dog’s body than collars, poorly fitted or poorly designed harnesses can cause chafing or irritation, particularly around the armpits or chest area. Make sure to choose a harness that is adjustable and fits your dog properly to prevent discomfort.

READ ALSO: Beneficial Supplements to Include in Dog Food

When to Use a Collar vs. a Harness

Collars Are Best For:

• Dogs that are calm and do not pull on the leash.
• Short walks or quick trips outside.
• Dogs with no neck issues or respiratory concerns.
• Dogs who need to wear identification tags constantly.
• Well-trained dogs that don’t require extra control during walks.

Harnesses Are Best For:

• Dogs that tend to pull on the leash or lunge.
• Puppies or small breeds with sensitive necks.
• Dogs with respiratory issues or breeds that are prone to neck problems.
• Long walks or outdoor adventures that require more comfort.
• Dogs that escape from collars easily.

FAQ Section

Which is better for a dog that pulls, a collar or a harness?

A harness is generally better for dogs that pull because it distributes pressure more evenly across their body. A no-pull harness with a front clip can help redirect their pulling behavior, providing more control without causing neck strain.

Is a collar safer than a harness?

Both collars and harnesses are safe when used properly. However, for dogs that pull, a collar can cause neck injuries, while a harness reduces the risk of harm by distributing the pressure across the dog’s body. If your dog pulls, a harness is often the safer option.

Can I use both a collar and a harness?

Yes, many dog owners use both a collar and a harness. The collar can be used for identification purposes, while the harness can be used during walks for added control and comfort. Just make sure the collar is snug but not too tight, and always check the harness for a proper fit.

Can I train my dog to walk with a collar if they pull?

It’s possible to train your dog to walk politely on a leash with a collar, but it may be more challenging. Training requires patience, consistency, and positive reinforcement. For dogs that pull significantly, a harness may provide more immediate control and prevent injury.

How do I know if my dog’s harness is the right size?

A properly fitted harness should be snug but not tight. You should be able to fit two fingers between the harness and your dog’s body. Pay attention to areas where the harness may rub or chafe, particularly around the chest and armpits.